Losing Cherish- And a Guide to Teaching Our Kids to be Safe

I had the chance to share this very important post on another site today (though it was written weeks ago)- it’s one I feel so strongly about, and hope that you’ll read and share.  It’s originally posted on Time’s Up Blog and I invite you to visit there to read more.  Though more than a month has past since this tragedy, we can’t forget.


Losing Cherish- And a Guide to Teaching Our Kids to be Safe


by Anita Davis Sullivan

Saturday, June 22nd, I think you could hear our corner of Florida wail. It wasn’t the first time that something tragic has happened, but it was fresh and raw. Many of awoke that Saturday morning to reports of the abduction of 8 year old Cherish Perrywinkle the previous night. Shortly after, we learned that Donald Smith, the prime suspect, had been arrested during a traffic stop, with no sign of Cherish. And a very short time later, we learned that the body of 8 year old Cherish had been found, near the Walmart she was abducted from.

Within moments, there were questions. Why had the mother allowed the child to go with a man they had known for just a few hours? Why had the Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office not alerted the public sooner that there was a child abduction? Why did the FDLE not notify the Center for Missing and Exploited Children, which would have prompted the phone alerts for the Amber Alert?  Why had Donald Smith seemingly fallen through the cracks and not been treated as a Sexually Violent Predator as recommended by the Department of Children and Families 11 years ago?

I don’t know. No one has the answers yet.

And though I pray they come, and that other children may be saved by what our community learns through this tragic event, my focus quickly turned to how we can help those here now. I heard from parents who sat and talked with their children about ‘Stranger Danger’ or watched them ever closer this weekend. I heard from one mother who had the heartbreaking job of telling her 8 year old daughter that her good friend Cherish was forever gone.

And though we must teach our children, I fear that we teach them the wrong things too often. The real danger is not in strangers- even Cherish was taken and killed by someone who gained her mother’s trust, albeit in a few short hours. But it’s estimated that less than 5% of attacks on children are by a stranger.

We must focus on teaching our children what is appropriate behavior, and how to trust their instincts.

June 26, 2013 marked the six year anniversary of the day that my brother, Michael “Austin” Davis went missing from Jacksonville, Florida. He was an adult, and most likely wasn’t abducted. But from this experience sometimes comes a need to protect my children even more. To make sure that our family doesn’t lose another. So I do teach them, not to be afraid, but to:

  • Know what kind of touching is appropriate and inappropriate, and that it’s okay to say “No!” and get away from anything that makes them uncomfortable.
  • Know who we consider safe grownups are. These are the people in our circle that they should be able to trust. But always reminding them, that it’s okay to say “No!” to even these people if they’re uncomfortable.
  • Know that they never have to protect us. If someone threatens us if they don’t do what the person says, they don’t have to do it.
  • Get permission to go anywhere, and stay in groups.
  • Never help an adult without our permission. It can be a trick.

In six years of missing my brother, we’ve also had to deal with the question of how much to tell our oldest, who celebrated his 4th birthday just two days before his Uncle Austin went missing. No matter if it’s a lost family member or a lost friend, children grieve and need help doing so.

Here are my tips on helping your child through a time of loss:

  • Let them see your emotions.
  • It’s okay for them to know you’re sad, as it let’s them know it’s okay for them to be sad too.
  • Encourage them to share memories of their loved one.
  • Create a scrapbook or box of memories that they can look through and remember their loved one. Allow them to participate in adding to it. For example, my son has a great memory of my brother taking him fishing. I’d forgotten about it, but he hasn’t.
  • Communicate with caregivers.
  • Let teachers or caregivers know that your child may experience out of the norm behaviors as they cope with this. Let your child know they can talk to these adults in their lives about what they’re feeling.
  • Share stories with your kids.
  • Tell stories about the lost loved one as your kids grow, reminding them how much the person loved them, or would have loved seeing them grow. Keep them alive in the heart of the family, giving your kids a feeling of roots and love. My sons have limited family in their lives, but I always want them to know the love of family.
  • Be honest on a level they can understand.
  • When my brother was first missing, we didn’t know what to tell our son. We didn’t want to lie, but we don’t really know the truth. We don’t know where he is. We’ve come to realize that it’s okay to say “we don’t know but we won’t give up until we do” and keep the brutal details from him (like that we believe he killed himself). As he’s gotten older, we’ve added more details but always the truth as he could understand and cope with it.

There are no simple answers on how to keep your kids safe, or how to help them through a loss like this. Just as there are no easy answers on why this tragedy happened.

But on this anniversary of my brother’s disappearance, I do know that I can help educate parents, who truly just want to keep their kids safe.

Rest in peace Cherish. You will not be forgotten.


  1. I already shared this on Twitter because I think this topic is extremely important. Ever since the news came out about the three women abducted and abused for over 15 years, I’ve been convinced that we need to teach and drill into our children’s heads the horrors that are out there with strangers and how to manage those situations.

    It is very sad to hear about what happened to Cherish. When I was reading this, I couldn’t help but shiver because there is no reason for her life to end in such a tragic way. Rest in peace, Cherish; I hope your story will reach out to many other parents and children.
    Keith DuBarry recently posted…Sound-Color Synesthesia and WritingMy Profile

    • Thank you so much Keith. Though I will say, that I believe we don’t need to drill into their heads the dangers of strangers, because those dangers are so much less than the people they know statistically and by focusing on that, we miss the chance to teach them about any type of bad behavior from anyone, especially those we know.

  2. What an incredible story about Cherish and your brother. I lost my best friend in high school when her ex-boyfriend murdered her out of jealousy. I had just entered high school. We didn’t have counselors in place to talk to like they do in schools today. We were told to basically suck it up. It took years before I could come to terms with her death. Sounds like you are doing the best that you can with your son regarding his uncle’s disappearance. I wish you all the best.
    Penny McDaniel recently posted…The Art of Teen WhisperingMy Profile

  3. Anita, this is so well written and clear, with things which can be followed and role-modelled. So important. Thank you for spreading the word.
    Considerer recently posted…A reasonable mash-upMy Profile

  4. Anita,
    This is such an important topic and I commend you for sharing it and raising awareness. I’m doubly paranoid about my son – he does not have the language skills to be able to comprehend good touching and bad touching. It’s scary and awful and it breaks my heart that there are people in the world who would harm a little kid. I’m not clear on the details of this case of Cherish (I did go to the news site you referenced but didn’t really “get” how the mom let this guy take her daughter or the circumstances around it).
    Kristi Campbell recently posted…the freak-out over Y2K and scuba divingMy Profile

    • None of us really get how she let him take her either… sad all the way around.

      I’d be more protective if I was you too- it’s all about not letting fear drive what you teach your kids, but also knowing how to best help and parent their individual needs. Never easy! <3

  5. This is a great point. I saw one child advocate say that instead of ‘stranger danger’ we need to teach kids about ‘tricky people’ who could try to hurt/take them. We taught our son (4) to find a mom with her kids if he ever gets lost or separated from us. (Not even a police officer or person in a type of uniform because uniforms have been used to deceive.)

    • Yes, stranger danger creates fear that is unnecessary and can prevent them from getting help from those they need to- tricky people is a great concept.

Speak Your Mind


CommentLuv badge